fish in sea

Evelyn Verdín/Unsplash

Do Collagen Supplements Actually Work? A Nutritionist Cuts Through The Hype

By Belle Amatt

From marine versus bovine, to vegan alternatives and the role of vitamin C, talk of collagen is at an all-time high, and so is the confusion. Belle Amatt, Registered Nutritional Therapist (BSc Nutritional Medicine) and nutritionist at W-Wellness, cuts through the hype with the answers that actually matter.

Collagen conversations have dominated the world of wellness in 2026. A growing fascination with this structural protein is fuelling an ever-expanding market, placing collagen firmly at the centre of where beauty, nutrition, and healthy ageing collide. But it comes with plenty of questions, and the cynics are vocal, so let's get to the researched facts.

Peering behind the marketing hype, three questions are worth answering: what exactly is collagen, why is it so important to our health, and can taking a supplement really make a difference?

What is collagen and why do we need it?

Collagen is a major structural component of our connective tissues, providing strength, support and integrity to the skin, bones, tendons, ligaments, cartilage, blood vessels and more.

Types I, II and III account for most of the collagen in the body, and they're the types of collagen we see in supplements.  Type I is particularly abundant in skin, bone and tendons; type II is found mainly in cartilage; and type III is present in skin, muscles and blood vessels. Understanding these differences can help guide supplement choice. Type II collagen, for example, is commonly selected for joint and musculoskeletal support, while types I and III are more often used in formulations aimed at skin and connective tissue health.

Why does collagen decline?

Collagen is continually being broken down and rebuilt. Fibroblasts produce the majority of this compound in skin and connective tissue, while specialised cells produce collagen within bone and cartilage.

Ageing tips the balance between breakdown and renewal; collagen synthesis gradually slows while degradation increases. This is particularly relevant for mid-life women, as declining oestrogen during and after menopause has a particularly noticeable effect on collagen turnover, affecting not only skin structure and elasticity but also connective tissues throughout the body, including bone, cartilage, tendons and ligaments. It's this that makes supplementation of collagen particularly relevant during this life stage.

There are also various lifestyle factors that accelerate collagen breakdown, and being aware of these allows us to take some control over the protection of our collagen and thereby our own healthy ageing. UV exposure is a major driver: it ramps up the activity of enzymes called matrix metalloproteinases, including collagenases, which break down the collagen network.

Smoking is another contributing factor, while chronically high blood glucose can promote glycation, a process in which sugar molecules bind to collagen fibres, causing them to become stiffer, less flexible and less effective at supporting the tissues.

Poor protein intake and inadequate overall nutrition can also compromise the body's ability to maintain and rebuild connective tissue. Making sure you eat enough protein throughout the day is one of the simplest places to start when thinking collagen supply. However, while eating collagen-rich foods can provide the body with similar amino acids and collagen-derived peptides, the amount and peptide profile will vary considerably. Collagen supplements offer a more concentrated and standardised source, making it easier to achieve a consistent daily intake. This may be particularly relevant as more people reduce their meat consumption for health and sustainability reasons, and consequently may eat fewer collagen-rich cuts of meat and connective tissues.

It's also worth considering what actually happens to collagen during digestion. Well-formulated collagen products are already broken down into smaller peptides (look for the words ‘hydrolysed collagen’) before we consume them. During digestion, these are broken down further but not destroyed. Human studies have identified collagen-derived peptides in the bloodstream after supplementation, suggesting that they survive digestion and are absorbed into the body. 

Marine or bovine collagen?

There's considerable debate over whether marine or bovine collagen is more effective, and both have their advocates. Marine collagen, sourced from fish, is predominantly type I, while bovine collagen typically contains types I and III. Marine collagen is often promoted for skin health, while bovine collagen is marketed more broadly for skin, bone and connective tissue support. However, current research doesn't establish that one source is consistently more effective than the other. Studies suggest that the specific collagen peptides, their molecular weight and the formulation may be more important than whether the collagen comes from marine or bovine sources.

If you are sustainably focused, there are quality brands on the market which provide both marine and bovine options sourced from by-products of the food industry: marine typically from fish skins and scales, bovine from cattle hides and bones. It's a useful way of making use of materials that might otherwise be discarded, although responsible sourcing remains important.

What about vegan collagen?

For those following a plant-based diet, there are increasingly sophisticated vegan alternatives. Rather than supplying collagen directly, these formulations take a different approach, combining nutrients and plant-derived ingredients that support the body's own collagen production. They may include vitamin C, which is essential for collagen synthesis, alongside amino acids, zinc, copper and antioxidant-rich botanical extracts. The aim is to provide the building blocks and nutritional cofactors needed to encourage the body to make its own collagen, rather than supplementing with animal-derived collagen peptides.

Why is vitamin C included in many collagen formulas?

I often hear that vitamin C is included in a product to ensure “collagen is efficiently absorbed”. This isn't true, and I suspect it's a confusion with iron absorption. Vitamin C is essential for normal collagen formation, acting as a cofactor for certain enzymes that modify amino acids within the collagen molecule. These Vitamin C-dependent steps help to stabilise collagen's characteristic triple-helix structure and support the formation of strong connective tissue. Therefore, without sufficient vitamin C, collagen synthesis is impaired, which makes its inclusion a sensible ‘belt and braces’ approach, just not for the reason usually given.

The big question: Can collagen supplements make a difference?

The evidence for collagen supplementation is still evolving, and much of the positive research has been funded by the supplement industry itself. When researchers analysed studies according to their funding sources, industry-funded trials reported more positive results, while those without industry funding did not show statistically significant improvements in skin hydration or elasticity. This doesn't mean collagen supplementation cannot be beneficial, but it does mean we need more independent research before drawing firm conclusions.

I also feel we need to acknowledge the value of clinical and personal experience. My own experience of using collagen, alongside that of many of my clients, has been overwhelmingly positive. I've observed improvements in hair and nail quality, skin firmness, and visible skin changes, as well as musculoskeletal benefits.  Anecdotal evidence is not a substitute for controlled clinical research, but it does have its own worth.

The biological mechanisms are reassuring, too. Collagen peptides both provide amino acids for collagen synthesis and, in addition, certain peptides may act as signalling molecules, influencing the cells involved in collagen production.

The good news is that we have more knowledge of, and more control over, ageing well than ever before. We can take the reins: protecting our skin from excessive UV exposure, avoiding smoking, keeping blood glucose steady, eating adequate protein, and maintaining a nutrient-rich diet all help support collagen health.

Collagen supplementation offers one tool in the wellbeing kit to support that process, providing additional building blocks and, potentially, stimulating the body's own collagen production. Combined with sensible lifestyle choices, it can be a valuable addition to a proactive approach to skin health, connective tissue support and healthy ageing.


This piece offers general, evidence-based information, not personal medical advice. Check with your GP or a registered nutritionist before starting any new supplement, particularly if you’re pregnant, breastfeeding or managing a health condition.

You Might Like